Smut Swap 2019 Letter

Jump to
Likes
DNWs
Fandoms
221B Baker Towers
*Mycroft Holmes/Sherlock Holmes
*Sherlock Holmes/Lestrade
*Sherlock Holmes/James Moriarty
Killing Eve (TV 2018)
*Anna Leonova/Villanelle | Oksana Astankova
Marvel (Comics)
*Matt Murdock/Peter Parker
*Peter Parker/Flash Thompson
Raven Cycle - Maggie Stiefvater
*Noah Czerny/Richard Gansey III/Ronan Lynch
*Richard Gansey III/Joseph Kavinsky
*Richard Gansey III/Ronan Lynch
*Declan Lynch/Matthew Lynch
*Declan Lynch/Ronan Lynch
*Matthew Lynch/Ronan Lynch

Hello! This is my first time participating in Smut Swap and I am so excited. Like !!! I can’t wait to get my assignment. This is gonna be great! Not every tag will be addressed my prompts because I feel that some of them speak for themselves. Some of my prompts are longer than others, but I’m equally enthusiastic about all of them (I just had more to say about certain ones). My ao3 is also summerdayghost, and if you have any questions or need anything clarified about this letter don’t be afraid to contact me through the mod. I hope you have a wonderful exchange whoever you are.

Likes
Terrible people in love
Drifters
Violence
Blood
Bruises
Fluff with disturbing subtext
Horror presented as fluff
Straight up horror
Straight up fluff
Fridge horror
Roadtrips
Character study
Guilt
Casefic
Begging
Taunting/Teasing
Dirty talk
Internal Conflict
Different moral alignment aus
Complicated and/or messed up relationships
Being brought over to the dark side
Fake relationships becoming real relationships
Dramatic irony
Manipulative relationships
Dubcon/noncon
Enthusiastic consent
Dark comedy
Secrets
Dirtybadwrong
Power dynamics
Power imbalance
Mentor/protégé
Grand gestures (both of the poorly and well received variety)
Oral sex
Frottage
Riding
Roleplay (the more tongue and cheek while also kinda sincere the better)
Characters being put on pedestals they can’t live up to
Frantic fully clothed take me now sex
Slow deliberate love making
Possessive sex
Cuddling

DNWs
Recreational drug use or references to recreational drug use (alcohol and cigarettes are fine as are depictions of drug addiction)
Watersports/scat
Bestiality
Genderbending that turns m/m or f/f into m/f
Sexual content featuring characters under the age of 15 (handwaving or not specifying ages works just fine)
Unrequested ship content
Unrequested trans headcanons
Pregnancy
a/b/o

Now here’s the prompts!

221B Baker Towers

Five second fandom is probably a more accurate description of 221B Baker Towers than five minute fandom. If you click this link you will have consumed the entire canon. All two hundred and fifty-three words of it. Beyond that you can basically do whatever you want with it. This blog is entirely dedicated to what people on tumblr have done with the idea, but since it’s all essentially fanon anyway you can take what you want and leave what you don’t. I’d love to see what your version of this universe is like, and I’ll try to find a good balance between actual prompts and creative freedom. Also the reason these are all tagged as Underage and No Archive Warnings Apply is that while we know Sherlock is young in this we don’t know exact ages so if he’s over eighteen young or under eighteen young is up to you.

Mycroft Holmes/Sherlock Holmes

Tags: Age Difference, Antagonism Leads to Sex, Character Study through Porn, Competitiveness in Bed, Daddy Kink, Degrading Praise, Dirty Talk, Emotional Manipulation, Cigarette Kink, Gentle Sex, Getting off on discomfort, Intelligence Kink, Intercrural Sex, Knowing It’s Wrong but Doing it Anyway, Lap Sex, Loss of Virginity, Making Amends With Sex, Making Out, Marking - Bruises and Bite Marks, Maybe-It’s-Not-Hate-Sex Sex, Morning After, overly formal courtship or request for sex, Political Debate as Foreplay, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Reconciliation Sex, Rough Sex, Sex After Serious Injury, Sharing a Bed, stress relief through sex, Touch-Starved, Under desk/table blowjob, Undercover as a Couple, Undercover Job Takes a Bad Turn

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

Who is this Mycroft Holmes? Is he a youth pastor? If so has he significantly impacted the lives of any of the Baker Street Irregulars (who in this universe are Sherlock’s peers rather than underlings) and has that in turn affected Sherlock somehow? Is he a politician? What is his platform? If he has made campaign promises of the cleaning up the streets and the improving the lives of the lower classes sorts, does Sherlock believe him to be sincere? What does Sherlock think of Mycroft’s politicking in general? Is he a police officer? What is his view on Sherlock’s sleuthing? How does Sherlock feel about his brother being a cop? Or does Mycroft have some other profession I haven’t thought of?

What is their dynamic like? I can’t imagine a Mycroft and Sherlock who don’t have problems with one another to some extent (and even if I could I don’t think I would be too interested), but what are the problems that plague this incarnation of them specifically? Are these issues that can be resolved? Do either of them want a better relationship with their brother and if so do they take any steps to try and make that happen? What are their interactions like at their best? What are their interactions like at their absolute rock bottom messiest worst? I would love it if they thought of themselves as complete opposites when in reality they have way more in common than either of them would ever admit.

When they fight what is it about? How often do they fight? How far does it go? Do these fights (verbal or physical) ever get sexual? I like the idea of them being able to verbally cut each other down like no one else can even if they aren’t fighting.

Despite everything, what do they absolutely love about each other? What can’t they help but admire? Do they try to keep it close to the chest or are they very open about the parts about each other that they like hoping to encourage those traits? This is likely tied to the issues between them, but what traits do they absolutely hate about each other?

Even if they want nothing to do with each other I like the idea of them being very possessive and overprotective of each other. No matter what that’s their brother. The way I’m seeing it it this behavior being on an intentional and overt level for Mycroft towards Sherlock and on a subconscious level for Sherlock towards Mycroft.

How much older is Mycroft than Sherlock and how does it factor into their relationship? If Mycroft is much, much older did their having grown up separately create a divide? If the age gap is smaller than how did the two of them end up on different life paths? Either way does Mycroft expect Sherlock to look up to him? Does some part of Sherlock crave Mycroft’s approval and he hates it? I can see Sherlock rejecting any overt attempts Mycroft might make at trying to be more of a mentor figure towards Sherlock while simultaneously holding some resentment at Mycroft for not being there to guide him when he needed it most.

I think the most important questions I have are what does Mycroft want from Sherlock and what does Sherlock want from Mycroft and how are those wants at odds.

Since this is Smut Swap and I think before this point I only brought up sex once this is my paragraph to amend that. How did the sexual element of their relationship come about? Is it just starting or has it always been there? Who would have initiated this? How does it play into and affect the rest of their dynamic? Is it exceedly awkward at times or does it typically play smoothly? Are they rough or gentle with each other? Does any of the competitiveness from their day to day lives leak into the bedroom? Is the sexual relationship purely sexual or is there a romantic relationship there as well? Also I tagged Daddy Kink, and it’s entirely optional (just like every tag and all of my prompts), but if you do choose to make that a thing how did that get into the bedroom? Is it something both of them like or just one of them?

Sherlock Holmes/Lestrade

Tags: Abuse of Authority, Age Difference, Antagonism Leads to Sex, Blowjobs, Casual Sex Leading to Feelings, Character Study through Porn, Courtship/Wooing, Daddy Kink, Degrading Praise, Desk Sex, Dirty Talk, Emotional Manipulation, Cigarette Kink, Frottage, Gentle Sex, Intelligence Kink, Knowing It’s Wrong but Doing it Anyway, Lap Sex, Loss of Virginity, Loyalty Kink, Maybe-It’s-Not-Hate-Sex Sex, Morning After, Nearly Getting Caught, not knowing identity of partner until after sex, Playful Sex, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Power Dynamics, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Riding, Rough Sex, stress relief through sex, Trading Sex for Favors, Undercover as a Couple, Undercover Job Takes a Bad Turn

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

I see Lestrade as still being a cop in this universe. If you have a different idea, I’ll be all for it, but these prompts for the most part will operate under the assumption he’s a cop. How does Sherlock’s relationship with Lestrade compare to his interactions with the rest of the police force? I really like the idea of Lestrade being the only one to give him the time of day, but Lestrade simply being the one that has to deal with Sherlock nine times out of ten could work as well. Black Lestrade is definitely my mental default when thinking about this universe for reasons I don’t really have the space/time to fully explore here. I mean I could but this is already shaping up to be a long letter. It’s mostly what it would mean for Lestrade’s character and his interactions with Sherlock. But if you feel something else would work better for your story go ahead.

What is the dynamic between them like? I tried my best to pick tags so there are places to go no matter which route you choose from friendly and benevolent to downright antagonistic. I’m here for it all. How does Lestrade feel about Sherlock’s sleuthing? When it comes to solving mysteries does Sherlock see Lestrade as a roadblock or a resource? What do they want from each other?

At what point did their relationship become sexual? Did Sherlock have a one night stand with Lestrade without knowing anything about him and then encountered him as a cop later? Or did their sexual relationship only come about after working together on a few cases? Maybe during one of them? Are things different between them in the bedroom than they are in the outside world? What are they getting out of this? Does their relationship have a romantic aspect as well as a sexual one?

Sherlock Holmes/James Moriarty

Tags: Abuse of Authority, Age Difference, Antagonism Leads to Sex, Blowjobs, Character Study through Porn, Corruption, Courtship/Wooing, Degrading Praise, Emotional Manipulation, Cigarette Kink, Fighting as Foreplay, Getting off on how much partner trusts them, Getting Together, Intelligence Kink, Intercrural Sex, Interrogation, Knifeplay, Loss of Virginity, Loyalty Kink, Making Amends With Sex, Marking - Bruises and Bite Marks, Mind Games, not knowing identity of partner until after sex, Obsession, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, Psychological Grooming, Riding, Sadism, Seduction to the Dark Side, Sex for Favors, Sex to Maintain Cover Identity, Sleepy Sex, Teacher/Student Roleplay, Turned On By Violence, Twisted and Fluffy Feelings, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

Who is this Moriarty? Is he a white collar criminal messing things up on a corporate level? Is he a drug runner looking to expand? Does he rule a criminal empire that runs the docks? Is he a murderer that managed to escape public notice until Sherlock saw a pattern? Is he some other kind of criminal mastermind entirely? Is Moriarty a rich man? If so did he have to work his way up to the top or was he born into privilege? Or is Moriarty a poor man? If so does he feel he would have taken a different path if he’d had better opportunities in life? I’d love it if Moriarty wasn’t white, but it isn’t a dealbreaker for me if he is. I think one thing that fascinates me about the Moriarty of this verse is that he still has be recognizably, well, the Moriarty of the story even if he isn’t necessarily who Sherlock would consider his arch nemesis.

I would like it if Moriarty genuinely liked Sherlock from the get go. He sees something in him and he loves it. He wants it. The ways Sherlock could initially feel about Moriarty may vary, (from hatred to fascination to respect to some combination to something else entirely) but it would be wonderful if there was some degree of mutual obsession (even if it isn’t entirely equal obsession).

Do they have any sort of past? Was he once important to Sherlock, a mentor of sorts, and if so how did they go their separate ways? Or maybe it was simply a one night stand and neither of them understood the significance of exactly who they were sleeping with at the time? Or have their paths only just now crossed because of the mysteries? They’re total strangers yet some of the most important people in one another’s lives.

I love basically every hero/villain ship trope and feel free to use them, and I have a huge weakness for stories where Moriarty somehow gets Sherlock to come over to the dark side and I’m I would love it if I saw it with these incarnations of the characters.

I have the tag Teacher/Student Roleplay because the original Moriarty was Professor Moriarty and I think that could be a delightful way to nod to that without necessarily making this Moriarty a professor.

Killing Eve (TV 2018)

Reveals are going to happen after season two starts up. I plan to keep with with this show as best as I can so if there is anything about my requested relationship in season two (which is unlikely but a girl can dream) that you would like to include in your fic feel free.

The reason this is tagged as Underage and Not Archive Warnings Apply is that I’m not entirely sure how old Villanelle was when they were together and have gotten conflicting answers from people I’ve asked. So it’s up to you if she was over eighteen or under it or if her age is unspecific. Any way you go with will work fine for me.

Anna Leonova/Villanelle | Oksana Astankova

Tags: Blood Kink, Character Study through Porn, Corruption, Courtship/Wooing, Cuddlefucking, Cunnilinigus, Desk Sex, Devotion, Dirty Photographs, Emotional Manipulation, Fingerfucking, Forbidden/Secret Relationships, Gentle Sex, Grinding, Guilt Over Desire Due to it Being Illegal or Immoral, Hair-pulling, Hair Kink, Jealousy leads to possessive sex, Kneesocks, Knifeplay, Language Kink, Lingerie, Marking - Bruises and Bite Marks, Morning Sex, Neck Kissing, Neediness, Obsession, Playful Sex, Porn with Feelings, Power Dynamics, Praise Kink, Psychological Grooming, Shower Sex, Touch-Starved, Tribadism, Twisted and Fluffy Feelings, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

This ship is so much my jam it’s hard to explain. Like it just hit so many specific weak spots of mine all at once and it’s glorious. What I wanna see is more of what their relationship was pre-canon. Like how did they get together and what was it like when they were together? I’m here for everything from sappy love making to rough crazy sex. Give me unhealthy codependency and obssession. Give me Oksana head over heels. Give me Oksana jealousy over Anna’s husband. Did Oksana ever go overboard trying to give Anna nice things? Did Anna feel any guilt about the relationship? What are some of the more fucked up fluffy things that happened between them? The Language Kink tag is there because Anna was a language teacher, and I mean, that’s one way to exploit that. We know Oksana loved Anna’s hair so feel free to go wild with that information. Just make it twisted and heartfelt.

Marvel (Comics)

I didn’t have any intention of requesting any Marvel for this exchange but then I saw these two pairings in the tagset. I was surprised and excited to see that a not-me person nominated these pairings and whoever they are is entirely to blame. Also they’re great and I hope they had a nice day.

Matt Murdock/Peter Parker

Tags: Age Difference, Casual Sex Leading to Feelings, Catholic Guilt, Celebratory Sex, Character Study through Porn, Consensual But Not Safe or Sane, Danger/Adrenaline Kink, Dirty Talk, Dubious Consent, Fighting as Foreplay, Gentle Sex, Guilt Over Desire Due to it Being Illegal or Immoral, Held Down, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Intercrural Sex, Lap Sex, Laughter During Sex, Morning After, Nearly Getting Caught, Neck Kissing, Playful Sex, Possessive Behavior, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Riding, Rough Sex to Stave off Other Violent Urges, Sex After Fighting/Battle, Sleepy Sex, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Trust Kink, Turned On By Violence, Under desk/table blowjob, Undercover as a Couple, Undercover Job Takes a Bad Turn, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

These two have known each other for a very long time and I ship it whole way down. The reason this request is tagged with both Underage and No Archive Warnings Apply because you can set it anywhere in the timeline and I’ll be happy. Peter be in high school or in college or be a college grad or be a high school teacher or any point in the timeline really and I’ll be into it. Although it does work best for if they have an age difference and it matters to Matt and Matt feels some degree of guilt about it. Peter could be old enough that the age difference genuinely doesn’t matter anyone and the age difference would still matter to Matt and Matt would feel some degree of guilt about because Matt is Matt. Peter is no stranger to the concept of guilt but he is far less likely to feel guilt about being with Matt for being with Matt’s sake.

Peter’s anger issues and violent tendencies are character traits that are vastly underrated by fandom. I feel like the messy, bloody, things are barely being held together quality the Daredevil corner of Marvel has from time to time is an excellent light to put Peter in. I like that being a good person isn’t what comes to Peter naturally and that he has to work at it and put effort into it. On a similar note these two have the potential to bring out the worst in each other in the absolute best ways. Individually they can be train wrecks but they might come together and become an airplane crash catastrophe. They have a lot of issues and there are a lot of ways their relationship could be beyond fucked and I’m here with popcorn.

On the flip side I think they could be great together. They’ve known each other for a while and they’ve known things about each other not many can know and there’s a lot of familiarity there. They’re comfortable with each other. They have senses of humor that compliment each other nicely. There is a lot of trust between them which is remarkable considering the trust issues they both have. They see each other as someone they can rely on. I’m just sayin that their history has made them fit nicely together.

I definitely like the idea of sex being the result of a sparring match getting too heated or sex happening for the first time in Matt’s office. Just yes.

I tagged Sugar Daddy Kink because Matt Murdock would a horrible sugar daddy. The man has no money. No money. So seeing him trying to be one anyway or just falling into a relationship that mirrors that sort of thing would be comedy gold as far as I’m concerned.

Peter Parker/Flash Thompson

Tags: Antagonism Leads to Sex, Blowjobs, Careful Sex Because Partner Is Bruised, Character Study through Porn, Courtship/Wooing, Degrading Praise, Devotion, Fighting as Foreplay, Forced to Confess Sexual Fantasies to Desired Partner, Gentle Sex, Grinding, Hand Jobs, Hate Sex, Held Down, Identity Porn, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Intelligence Kink, Initial dubcon/coercion leading to feelings, Just the Tip turns into More than the Tip, Laughter During Sex, Making Amends With Sex, Maybe-It’s-Not-Hate-Sex Sex, Neck Kissing, not knowing identity of partner until after sex, Obsession, Playful Sex, Possessive Behavior, Post-Coital Cuddling, Protectiveness, Rape to keep the victim in line, Riding, Sex After Serious Injury, Sex to Maintain Cover Identity, stress relief through sex, Strength Kink, Touch-Starved, Turned On By Violence, Victim doesn’t fight back, Victim Treated Like a Lover, Victim Trying to Pretend They're Having Sex Consensually

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply, Rape/Non-Con

The relationship between these two has grown and developed a lot throughout the years. They’ve been a lot of things to each other. They started out as enemies and then there was that period where they weren’t enemies anymore but they weren’t quite friends and then that time when a friendship blossomed between them despite themselves. At one point they were arguably best friends (Flash was the best man at Peter’s wedding after all). I’m invested throughout the whole process, and I’ll be happy with fic set throughout any point in that journey (even if the events of that fic likely would have sent that journey in a slightly different direction, hell depending on the direction especially so). I tagged this as both Underage and No Archive Warnings Apply because for the beginning of that timeline they are both underage high school students but they don’t stay that way so it all depends on when you set it. Similarly I tagged both Rape/Non-Con because I am fine with any level of consent between these two.

Okay so I definitely have a weakness for fic where Flash sees bruises on Peter and it makes him worry. Especially if it’s in the bullying era (and he knows there’s no way he left those bruises in particular) or the no longer enemies but not yet friends era of their relationship. Especially, especially if Flash doesn’t yet know Peter is Spider-Man and comes to his own conclusions. I love it every time, and I wish I could have every possible variant of this very specific scenario.

Flash being Spider-Man’s biggest fan while also having the relationship with Peter that he does has always been something I’ve found interesting. I encourage you to exploit that to hell and back. It’d be great if Flash had a thing for both Spider-Man and Peter Parker (or if he had a thing for one but not the other). Identity porn is always fun. If you go with the “Forced to Confess Sexual Fantasies to Desired Partner” tag Flash confessing his fantasies about Spider-Man to Peter or his fantasies about Peter to Spider-Man would be great. Of course Peter confessing fantasies to Flash would also be fun.

Strength kink because it’s just perfect for this pairing. Flash not realizing Peter is way stronger than him until Peter gets the upper hand and then is surprised at how into it he is. Peter pretending he is weaker than Flash and that Flash is oh so strong and enjoying it also works. It all works. On a tangential note Peter having a thing for violence and that making things complicated is yet another thing that works.

“Just the Tip turns into More than the Tip” just seems like the most ridiculous idiot teenager first time trope, and thus I couldn’t resist putting it in there. It could be beautiful.

I should mention that with all of the noncon tags, I tagged them with the assumption that if you chose to go use one of those for the story you write that Flash would be the one nonconning Peter (with the exception of “Initial dubcon/coercion leading to feelings”, I can easily imagine either being the coercer there). If wanna flip the script on me that could be interesting, but I’m not sure it would be an easy feat. Mostly because that part of canon where Flash is bullying Peter is a setting where fic of Flash nonconning Peter can be easily inserted, but I can’t think of a part of canon that would Peter nonconning Flash would be easily inserted. After typing that sentence I immediately thought “AU where Uncle Ben wasn’t shot and Peter wants revenge against Flash”, which I mean, I would be down.

I tried my best to have it so that this request had tags that could inspire fucked up dubcon or noncon and tags that could inspire friends to lovers so fluffy it rots your teeth. Those are directions I would be happy to receive as are every direction in between. I love it when they just hate each other so much, and I love it when they just love each other so much. I have a lot of love in my heart for this pairing, okay. A lot.

Raven Cycle - Maggie Stiefvater

I finally finished this series which means I can feel comfortable requesting this for exchanges. Yay!

Noah Czerny/Richard Gansey III/Ronan Lynch

Tags: Character Study through Porn, Courtship/Wooing, Cuddlefucking, Daddy Kink, Devotion, Dirty Talk, Discipline, Dom/sub, Enthusiastic Consent, Frottage, Gentle Sex, Getting off on how much partner trusts them, Hand Holding during sex, Intercrural Sex, Kiss of Life, Laughter During Sex, Making Out, Morning After, Morning Sex, Neck Kissing, Neediness, Playful Sex, Porn with Feelings, Post-Coital Cuddling, Power Dynamics, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Restraints, Riding, Sadism, Sexual Roleplay, Sharing a Bed, Sleepy Sex, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Threesome - dominant couple/submissive third, Time Traveler Has Sex With Love Interest Who is Dead in Their Future

Archive Warnings: Underage

One thing I always love is Noah saying/doing alive things as a way of essentially playing house. Y’know stuff like complaining about the whether as if it affects him or pretending to want a waffle iron. Look, I know this is very specific and probably only appeals to me, but just that sense of playing house going further and ends up having this extra dimension with the implication that they are a nuclear family with Gansey and Ronan as the parents and Noah as their child. Maybe the words are never actually said out loud but the sense of it is there and it’s getting stronger and they all feel it and ends up getting sexual. Their dynamic being depicted in such a way would be very good for me.

I put “Sugar Daddy Kink” in there because Gansey is always gonna be Gansey and a part of being Gansey is the urge to sugar daddy his friends. He can’t help it. Poor thing. “Kiss of Life” is in there because if they somehow resurrected Noah midcoitus that could be fun. And then “Time Traveler Has Sex With Love Interest Who is Dead in Their Future” because that has the potential to make me laugh and rip my heart out. Especially if it was Noah’s first and only time while alive.

I picked tags on this one for their fluff potential and for their Dom/sub kinky potential because both. Both are good. Especially at the same time for this triad.

Richard Gansey III/Joseph Kavinsky

Tags: Antagonism Leads to Sex, Blowjobs, Car Sex, Character Study through Porn, Consensual But Not Safe or Sane, Competitiveness in Bed, Daddy Kink, Degrading Praise, Dirty Talk, Forced Deepthroat/Choking on a Dick, Forced to Kneel, Forced to enjoy it, Fucked until unconscious, Hate Sex, Held Down, Knifeplay, Lap Sex, Marking - Bruises and Bite Marks, Neediness to Please, Non-Consensual Kissing, Obsession, Possessive Behavior, Rape to keep the victim in line, rapist wants to hear victim make sounds, Riding, Role Reversal, Rough Sex to Stave off Other Violent Urges, Seduction to the Dark Side, Sex creates soul bond, Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm, Stalking Escalates to Rape, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Truth or Dare, Turned On By Violence, Under desk/table blowjob, Victim Treated Like a Lover, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply, Rape/Non-Con

This is tagged with both Underage and No Archive Warnings Apply because the timeline of this series is so screwy and unrelated to math that if you want them to be underage they can be and if you don’t they don’t have to be. Also this is tagged with No Archive Warnings Apply and Rape/Non-Con because I would be happy receiving any level of consent for this pairing. Although with my tags specifically about noncon I did tag them with the assumption that Kavinsky would be nonconning Gansey and all the prompts directly addressing those tags will be written with that assumption. If you wanna write it the other way around feel free to. If you can make that work I’m sure I’ll be into it.

Okay so first things first daddy kink. I distinctly remember Kavinsky referring to Gansey as daddy more than once. I know it was in a mocking way, but I think it would be great if didn’t stop mocking Gansey like that just because they were having sex. Maybe it just makes him double down. Speaking of mocking Gansey, what is the worst thing that Kavinsky could say to him? Just give me Kavinsky being really cruel to Gansey in general. Even if you go with the Victim Treated Like a Lover tag because I don’t think Kavinsky would be all that kind to his lovers. The being treated like a lover part would have to be apparent though an aspect of his behavior other than outward niceness.

The sugar daddy tag is there for two reasons. The first is because it’s Gansey’s natural instinct. The second is because with Kavinsky’s dream powers I think a story where Kavinsky tries to insert himself in that type of role as a power play could be REALLY interesting.

Seduction to the dark side is there because that is one of my favorite things. I don’t how it would happen but I would be very interested in finding out. Plus dark!Gansey is something I need in my life. Similarly role reversal is there because I have no idea what a role reversal au between these two would even look like but I’m already invested.

Sex creates a soul bond and soul marks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm are there because the idea of these two as soulmates is something else. It would be a disaster. It would be beautiful. The difference between these tags is that the former implies that this is entirely their fault and they’ll have to live with it forever (and whether or not they knew this would happen going in is a good question) while the later implies it had always been this way just hidden. Also I tend to interpret that later tag more so first orgasm from soulmate than first orgasm ever.

I like the idea of Kavinsky just not being able to get his mind off of Gansey no matter how hard he tries. It makes his thoughts more and more twisted as time goes on. This probably won’t end well.

Richard Gansey III/Ronan Lynch

Tags: Blood Kink, Blowjobs, Car Sex, Catholic Guilt, Character Study through Porn, Daddy Kink, Danger/Adrenaline Kink, Devotion, Dirty Talk, Discipline, Dom/sub, Frottage, Getting off on how much partner trusts them, Hand Jobs, Heresy/Sacrilege Kink, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Jealousy leads to possessive sex, Knifeplay, Lap Sex, Loyalty Kink, Marking - Bruises and Bite Marks, Masochism, Morning After, Neck Kissing, Neediness, Porn with Feelings, Post-Coital Cuddling, Power Dynamics, Praise Kink, quiet intimacy, Restraints, Riding, Rough Sex, Sadism, Sex creates soul bond, Sharing a Bed, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink

Archive Warnings: Underage, No Archive Warnings Apply

This is tagged with both Underage and No Archive Warnings Apply because the timeline of this series is so screwy and unrelated to math that if you want them to be underage they can be and if you don’t they don’t have to be.

I think these two were made for Dom/sub dynamics with Gansey as the Dom and Ronan as the sub. At least to some extent. Even if it’s informal and the words are never said (which would probably actually work better for me) just the dynamic, the feeling still has to be there. I didn’t tag blood kink, discipline, knifeplay, marking - bruises and bite marks, masochism, restraints, rough sex, and sadism for nothing. Go wild with all the crazy, kinky, rough sex stuff you can dream of for these two. I’ll love every second of it. But also I want it to be extremely loving blood kink, discipline, knifeplay, marking - bruises and bite marks, masochism, restraints, rough sex, and sadism. I don’t mean in the make it soft way. Not at all. Anything but that. I mean in the they love each other a lot and this is how they express it way.

Catholic guilt and heresy/sacrilege kink are both there because I feel those are things you could exploit to hell and back and it could be wonderful. Daddy kink is there because these boys definitely have daddy issues and this is a fun way to explore that. Sugar daddy kink because as I’ve said earlier in this letter, it’s Gansey’s natural instinct, and I’d love to see Ronan’s reaction to him trying to pull that. Sex creates a soul bond because I just really like the idea of that trope applied to these two. Also for the jealousy leads to possessive sex tag, who is jealous and why?

Declan Lynch/Matthew Lynch

Tags: Catholic Guilt, Character Study through Porn, Daddy Kink, Devotion, Frottage, Gentle Sex, Guilt Over Desire Due to it Being Illegal or Immoral, Hand Jobs, Huddling for Warmth Leads to Sex, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Jealousy leads to possessive sex, Knowing It’s Wrong but Doing it Anyway, Lap Sex, Laughter During Sex, Loss of Virginity, Making Out, Morning After, Nearly Getting Caught, Neck Kissing, Neediness to Please, Obsession, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Religion Kink, Riding, Sex After Serious Injury, Sex Pollen - affecting both/all, Sharing a Bed, Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Touch-Starved, Twisted and Fluffy Feelings, Under desk/table blowjob, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage

If you set this at some point during the timeline where Matthew is more likely to be fourteen than fifteen, as long as you don’t draw attention to his age/really mention it, it’ll be fine.

I really like the idea of Declan being really possessive of Matthew because of issues connected to Ronan and Niall (or any other issues, Declan has a lot of issues). On some level he just wants to protect and have and keep him. He doesn’t want to let go and trust the world. Maybe these instincts could lead him to try to spoil Matthew just a little bit (or a lot a bit). Also Declan being worried about Matthew is my jam.

For the “Sex After Serious Injury” tag I’d love it if one of them was very hurt and the sex was the other’s way if trying to comfort them. If it’s Matthew it’s clumsy and sweet and maybe a little misguided but Declan appreciates it anyway. If it’s Declan it’s an attempt to comfort himself in some ways and reaffirm something (even if he’d never admit it to himself) and he’s filled with anger at whatever hurt Matthew.

The metaphysical/magical implications of Matthew being Declan’s soulmate are fascinating to me. Since Matthew is a created thing it would mean in some way he was created for Declan as well as in response to Declan. Just what would that mean for the whole dream thing mechanics if Matthew can be a soulmate or if Declan’s soulmate is a dream thing? I picked “Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm” specifically because I feel like that’s a really dramatic way to find out and it could be fun (for me, probably not them).

As for the sex pollen tag do either of them try to resist it or are they both too far gone by the time they realize what happened? Do either of them feel any guilt about it afterwards or during? Does this lead to relationship somehow?

Declan Lynch/Ronan Lynch

Tags: Catholic Guilt, Character Study through Porn, Daddy Kink, Devotion, Frottage, Gentle Sex, Guilt Over Desire Due to it Being Illegal or Immoral, Hand Jobs, Huddling for Warmth Leads to Sex, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Jealousy leads to possessive sex, Knowing It’s Wrong but Doing it Anyway, Lap Sex, Laughter During Sex, Loss of Virginity, Making Out, Morning After, Nearly Getting Caught, Neck Kissing, Neediness to Please, Obsession, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Religion Kink, Riding, Sex After Serious Injury, Sex Pollen - affecting both/all, Sharing a Bed, Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Touch-Starved, Twisted and Fluffy Feelings, Under desk/table blowjob, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage

Their dynamic is just so dysfunctional and I love it. I really don’t have much to say about their dynamic except yes and I want more of it. It’s wonderful. Just all the love and hate and issues and fighting and understanding and misunderstanding in the world please.

The daddy kink tag is there because they both have daddy issues and if there was ever a time to exploit that it would be now. The sex pollen and soulmarks tags because those have the potential to be disasters and I love disasters. Also for sugar daddy kink who would be the sugar daddy and who would be the sugar baby? Who has the praise kink?

Also bickering during sex or using sex to shut each other up are both good ways to go about it.

Matthew Lynch/Ronan Lynch

Tags: Catholic Guilt, Character Study through Porn, Daddy Kink, Devotion, Frottage, Gentle Sex, Guilt Over Desire Due to it Being Illegal or Immoral, Hand Jobs, Huddling for Warmth Leads to Sex, Inappropriately timed emotional conversations, Jealousy leads to possessive sex, Knowing It’s Wrong but Doing it Anyway, Lap Sex, Laughter During Sex, Loss of Virginity, Making Out, Morning After, Nearly Getting Caught, Neck Kissing, Neediness to Please, Obsession, Porn with Feelings, Possessive Behavior, Praise Kink, Protectiveness, quiet intimacy, Religion Kink, Riding, Sex After Serious Injury, Sex Pollen - affecting both/all, Sharing a Bed, Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm, stress relief through sex, Sugar Daddy Kink, Touch-Starved, Twisted and Fluffy Feelings, Under desk/table blowjob, Warped Shows of Affection

Archive Warnings: Underage

If you set this at some point during the timeline where Matthew is more likely to be fourteen than fifteen, as long as you don’t draw attention to his age/really mention it, it’ll be fine.

One thing I definitely want is all the creepy parallels between Ronan and Matthew’s relationship and Niall and Aurora’s. Like the creepier the better. Give me all the fucked up implications you can imagine.

Matthew being drawn to Ronan sexually because Ronan is his creator, especially if Matthew doesn’t know that’s why he feels the way he feels. Just abuse the fact that Matthew is a dream thing and all the possible mechanics of it in any way possible for porn reasons. It’s the perfect thing to exploit. For the tags relating to possessive sex and behavior I definitely think that could be tied into the sorta thing that is the theme of this paragraph whether it’s Ronan being possessive or Matthew (I’m imagining Ronan more so as the possessive one but if you’re seeing it as Matthew then feel free).

The sugar daddy kink tag is there because I like the idea of Ronan wanting to give Matthew things because he’s so sweet and he dreams him gifts and it just spins into an out of control direction he didn’t intend. Relatedly and not relatedly, the daddy kink tag is there because there is the potential for great dramatic irony there.

I tagged “Soulmarks appear after your mate gives you your first orgasm” because I find the metaphysical implications of that for this pairing fascinating. What would that mean for Matthew to be Ronan’s soulmate? I picked that particular soulmark tag because that’s one hell of a way to find out. Also the sex pollen tag is there because that could be played for great fluff with a side of guilt or angst with a side of guilt.